Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Rusting Metal: A Last Look at Tempered Steel in Standard


Welcome back to Untap Target Player!

If you are here for the Tibbles and Bits list from the KlotzProductions video, click here!

I am a big fan of Magic variants; team or one on one, I like unusual rules and deck construction.  They give life to otherwise obscure or unplayable cards.  I love knocking dust off old binder cards and sleeving them up for an unusual format.  Pauper, Block Constructed, Planechase, Cube…tons of fun formats to test your deckbuilding skills.  One of the most popular variants, EDH, has been officially endorsed by Wizards of the Coast as “Commander.”  For me, though, EDH was already one of my favorite formats before it ever became official.  “Yeah, that’s right,” said Hipster Matt.  “I liked EDH before it was cool.”  Then I sipped on some PBR and smoked a hand-rolled cigarette while listening to an unreleased vinyl LP of James Taylor on my vintage RCA.

"Your Delver deck is sooo mainstream."
My interest in EDH began about half of my Magic career ago at PTQ San Diego.  It was Zendikar Sealed and I got there pretty early, so I sailed amongst the sea of Magic competitors.  The event was pretty big, a few hundred or so, and I sat down by a group of folks with their trade binders open and tall stacks of sleeved cards beside them.  I sat down and asked to trade, and they kindly capitulated.  They were talking about EDH; I inquired about their offbeat discussion, and they explained the format to me.  They gave me a crash course, too, allowing me to borrow one of their deck, a Bant colored squad with Rafiq of the Many at the helm, if I recall.  I played through and, although I didn’t do terribly well (the Rafiq deck was full of complex and sweet interactions and synergies), I knew I wanted to get started.  The first general that came to mind was Teneb, the Harvester, as he was multi-colored, a Dragon, and effective at delivering 21 points of general damage (central to the game, as I thought at the time.)  It was settled; until they called for seating, I flipped through my binders and boxes and began forming the deck. 

I completed it a couple weeks later and it was, how you say, super sweet.  Other generals came to mind, and I’ve since built and tested several generals and color combinations, including Doran, the Siege Tower (using the shell from my Teneb deck), Lyzolda, the Blood Witch, Tolsimir Wolfblood, Teferi, Mage of Zhalfir and, my current MTGO EDH deck, Kazuul, Tyrant of the Cliffs.  My most recent decks have revolved around Standard-legal generals, though not intentionally.  Olivia Voldaren was my “generalissima” for a while, and my Geist of Saint Traft tribal Spirit deck still finds its way into the occasional match.  However, my most recent EDH deck is probably the most fun one I’ve ever made.  My general is…

A sir.
Yeah, I’m about 98% sure that Gisela, Blade of Goldnight is a better General, but this guy.  THIS GUY.

With this Mirran general in the driver’s seat, I’ve stocked the deck to the brim with aggressive and powerful artifacts.  The deck performs consistently well in one-on-one and in multiplayer games of EDH, and it’s got plenty of tools, blow-out plays and unique interactions to create a fun and dynamic deck.  Here’s the list.

General
Jor Kadeen, the Prevailer

Creatures (32)

Bosh, Iron Golem
Mycosynth Golem
Porcelain Legionnaire
Scuttlemutt
Solemn Simulacrum
Kuldotha Forgemaster
Iron Myr
Gold Myr
Palladium Myr
Allow Myr
Myr Galvanizer
Platinum Angel
Stuffy Doll
Myr Enforcer
Shimmer Myr
Moltensteel Dragon
Pilgrim’s Eye
Goblin Replica
Slobad, Goblin Tinkerer
Cathodion
Master Splicer
Steel Overseer
Atog
Lodestone Golem
Pentavus
Jhoira’s Toolbox
Lodestone Myr
Slash Panther
Sanctum Gargoyle
Ethersworn Canonist
Manor Gargoyle
Perilous Myr

Spells (33)
Sensei’s Divining Top
Whispersilk Cloak
Umezawa’s Jitte
Phryexian Rebirth
Second Sunrise
Blasphemous Act
Thunder Totem
Forisiyan Totem
Soulscour
Scourglass
Dispeller’s Capsule
Orim’s Thunder
Candles of Leng
Darksteel Forge
Origin Spellbomb
Open the Vaults
Myr Matrix
Ur-Golem’s Eye
Expedition Map
Dispatch
Dawn Charm
Tempered Steel
Sunforger
Glint Hawk Idol
Norn’s Annex
Fury Charm
Disenchant
Ajani Vengeant
Boros Fury-Shield
Dispense Justice
Manalith
Pyrite Spellbomb
Boros Signet

Lands (34)
Vivid Crag
Vivid Meadow
Urza’s Tower
Urza’s Power Plant
Urza’s Mine
Urza’s Factory
Dread Statuary
Buried Ruin
Phryexia’s Core
Darksteel Citadel
Ancient Den
Great Furnace
Sunhome, Fortress of the Legion
Slayer’s Stronghold
Arid Mesa
Clifftop Retreat
Terramorphic Expanse
Evolving Wilds
Strip Mine
Tectonic Edge
Windbrisk Heights
New Benalia
Stalking Stones
Spirerock Knoll
Shimmering Grotto
5 Mountains
4 Plains

Is it the best deck?  No, probably not.  I, however, am loving playing it!  It does really well in a lot of situations and rarely comes up with a sour (or at least uninteresting) draw.  Most of the time, I just cast Jor Kadeen as an Overrun, but even alone with metalcraft, he’s an 8/4 first striker, which is enough to stop about anything except a huge Omnath.  Nevertheless, this is the most fun one I’ve made.  It’s aggro in a non-aggro format and it does it very efficiently and reliably.

As I was playing this the other day after a Standard tourney match, I drew and cast a Tempered Steel and politely smashed my opponent’s face.  I started thinking about the dominance that Tempered Steel enjoyed about 18 months ago.  Memnites, Glint Hawk Idols and Vault Skirges ruled the format.  It was the aggro deck for a long time, and people recognized it after turn one, usually because they’d played about three cards by then.  When Innistrad came out, everyone went nuts over Delver, and this deck dwindled back into obscurity.

As the five suns set on Scars of Mirrodin in just seven weeks, I’d like to give this once format-defining archetype a little makeover, M13 style!  Much of the core remains the same, but I want to make sure this is relevant in the current metagame while maintaining the flavor, tempo and aggression that the colors of Boros offer.  As I convert this top-heavy EDH deck into a Standard deck, here’s where I landed.

Tempered Skill

Creatures (21)

4 Vault Skirge
4 Porcelain Legionnaire
3 Vulshok Replica
3 Glint Hawk Idol
3 Immolating Souleater
2 Pierce Strider
2 Moltensteel Dragon

Spells (18)

4 Galvanic Blast
3 Tempered Steel
3 Whipflare
2 Mox Opal/Sphere of the Suns
2 Ajani, Caller of the Pride
2 Dispatch
2 Trading Post

Lands (21)

6 Mountain
7 Plains
4 Clifftop Retreat
2 Buried Ruin
1 Phryexia’s Core
1 Slayer’s Stronghold

Sideboard (15)

3 Faith’s Shield
3 Bonfire of the Damned
3 Oblivion Ring
2 Witchbane Orb
2 Tormod’s Crypt
2 Elixir of Immortality

Deck Tech – Creatures

Vault Skirge
A one mana flyer in any color?  Imp-possible!
The Skirge is an awesome creature, and he’s a perfect fit for this deck.  Highly reminiscent of everyone’s favorite Mourning Thrull from Guildpact and better in most every regard, this guy is the deck’s premier one-drop.  A staple in Standard artifact aggro, this guy can help you gain an edge in a race while also providing evasion and a beneficially pumping body to get in the red zone.  His exceptionally low cost is a major benefit in a deck that benefits from Metalcraft synergies.  Once the Steel is in play, he becomes a real haymaker. 

Porcelain Legionnaire

Kicking grout and fighting lime!
The Sink Soldier is also a very high value creature.  A 3/1 first-striker is more formidable in combat than just about anything else in the format at that CMC; it can safely block both halves of a Thragtusk!  Having one toughness is a fairly serious liability; a tiny Bonfire can kill him without help, but against non-damage related kill (Oblivion Ring, black kill spells), it won’t end up mattering.  If he sticks, you can be sure he’ll do a lot of work.  He’s a great topdeck, clogging up the ground with his big metallic face or providing a reasonable clock on an empty board. 

Vulshok Replica

Shoking.
A new face to the archetype, the Replica, on one hand, is Legionnaires 5-7, but on another, it’s a good non-combat way to bust in.  While a reasonable attacker, his ability to toss himself directly at the opponent at instant speed is not irrelevant.  He’s a Lava Spike on a stick, and in a deck that’s looking to go from 20-0 in a hurry, he can provide a little bit of reach.  Three seems like the right number of copies here, too.  My rule of thumb is that “you only want a playset if you don’t mind two in your opener,” and this is one of those that you want to draw around turn 5.

Glint Hawk Idol

If you don't have an artifact in hand, this guy is pretty hawkward.
This amazing artifact is another workhorse of Tempered Steel.  It has the fortunate creature-on-demand attribute to dodge sorcery-based creature removal, board wipes and other disadvantages of always being a creature.  The Idol is cheap, efficient, versatile AND an artifact, giving it a highlighted spot in this list.

Immolating Souleater

Intense name for a dog that dies to Sanctuary Cat.
By the time this card came out, Tempered Steel was already fading out of Standard’s top tables.  What would otherwise have been an excellent win condition instead showed its canine head in the occasional rogue deck here and there and as a cheap combo enabler for offbeat kitchen table decks.  Alongside Tempered Steel and the mana to actually pay his ability, I’m excited to give him a shot here.  Let’s eat some souls!

Pierce Strider

slurp slurp slurp...
An aggressive and reasonable body that passes the Vapor Snag test, this Bump in the Night on legs is right on curve for this deck.  A reasonable body, he can stop Huntmasters and piddly burn (Pillars of Flame or anemic Bonfires.)  I do need some value creatures in this deck, as I lack a real draw engine.  This guy is a welcome addition.  He does just fine here, though I’m not as attached to him as much as some of the other cards in here.

Moltensteel Dragon

Finally, a ferocious ferrous finisher!
Immolating Souleater 2.0 with wings.  This huge dragon is aggressively costed (a 4/4 flyer for 4) and difficult to burn out.  Also, he’s a great finisher, and how many “finishers” are at four mana?  Basically a Shivan Dragon once he’s in, he can snatch those last few points overhead with Phyrbreathing.  I’m excited to actually play him in Constructed!

Spells

Galvanic Blast

Arc you sure it's good?
Another staple of red artifact decks is the mighty Galvanic Blast.  Better than Lightning Bolt in most situations, this amazingly efficient spell kills over 80% of the creatures in Standard when online (I looked) and never gets worse than Shock.  Costing just one mana puts this thing firmly as a four-of in this deck.

Tempered Steel

Don't make it mad, this enchantment's got quite a....
This is the core of the deck.  Although the deck can function without it, it would rather not, and on a clogged board, this is my alpha strike.  This provides an immeasurably important boost to an otherwise shrimpy bunch of critters.  You always feel good to draw it, but you don’t normally need more than one, so three feels right on the money here.

Whipflare

Wah...PSHHH!!!
The sweeper of choice for this deck; all of my creatures dodge its effect, it’s cheap and low on color weight, and it can clear the way for my assault while generating card advantage.  An easy board-out in a low creature deck, this just wrecks U/W Delver, mana-dorks and tokens.  Even casting it on one creature is acceptable, so don’t be afraid to just Shock something with it!

Mox Opal

Isn't it ironic that the most expensive cards to buy are the cheapest to cast?
This beautiful gem is an odd inclusion in this deck.  As a legendary artifact, a second one in hand will often be dead, but if he’s up, he can provide fixing, metalcraft and ramp second to none in a deck like this.  It’s a risky inclusion, but it seems too synergetic to not include it.

Ajani, Caller of the Pride

The streamlined feline!
This cool cat provides an exceptional boost to this aggressive deck.  His first ability makes any of my fairly tinny artifact men a much better fighter. Non-spell +1/+1 counters forever are pretty nice, I hear.

That's what I hear.
His -3 ability synergizes perfectly with Immolating Souleater and Moltensteel Dragon, providing an instant win condition if you have comparable life totals.  His ultimate, while cute, will probably often be irrelevant with me living at a low life total.  I know Ajani’s been floating around, but I hadn’t seen him do a lot since his reprisal, but this seems like a strong place to start.

Dispatch

Dispatch is givin' me a rash, mon.
A cut-and-dry removal spell that, even without Metalcraft, can provide the essential bit of temporary removal I need for a more powerful strike.  Directly exiling a creature for W is fantastic, but I’m OK to cast this even when that’s not the case; the games with this deck should be tight enough that they provide essentially the same result for that crucial turn.

Trading Post
If you ever find a cooler artifact, keep me Posted.
Although people could fill whole shoeboxes with combo decks regarding this strangely artificial market, it provides a ton of depth for this deck and allows me to turn anything in my hand into a little life and anything on the table into a card at instant speed.  Casting this with a mana open makes me feel good, to say the least.  It synergizes really well with the artifact theme.  Also, I can’t wait to make a Goat, pump it with Ajani and swing for the win.  MVP Goat!

The LeBron James of this deck.
Mana Base

For an artifact deck, this deck is fairly color hungry, so the colorless lands are limited; each of those provides utility and flexibility.  Buried Ruin is sheer quality in the late game, recovering any artifact from the yard for the desired effect.

Sideboard

The sideboard is fairly metagame specific, stressing defensive cards like Faith’s Shield, Oblivion Ring (a nice blanket answer for nearly any permanent), Witchbane Orb against Burn, Bonfire of the Damned and Mill, and the Elixirs and Crypts lend well to Metalcraft while giving me protection against graveyards and races.  Bonfires of the Damned are just kind of in there to be in there.  Although that $40 bullet is good in most decks that can cast it, this may be one of the worst ones for it; low mana and trickiness with color makes Bonfire an awkward blank on occasion.  It’s possible I play some other form of burn or finisher here, but for now, auto-Bonfire probably fits the bill fine.  As with most of my sideboards, if one particular deck dominates your local shop, sideboard accordingly.

This deck has done very well against aggro and control in playtesting, outracing each while maintaining firm control on both life totals and board states.  The sideboard should give this deck some much needed flexibility against a wide variety of FNM-style decks.  Is this thing going to get to a top table at an SCG Open or a Grand Prix?  Probably not, but here’s to hoping. 

I have three decks on the burner right now, and I’m excited to play them out to see which I like most; Paint it Black (see last week), Tempered Skill, and a revision of Tibbles and Bits, Tibalt the Firebrand. 

Tibalt, the Firebrand: Deck and Testing

Tibalt, the Firebrand was kind of a knee-jerk build after disassembling an interesting control deck with Nicol Bolas in the captain’s seat.  What started as a mono-red brew found itself splashing a pinch of black for improved effectiveness.  At Friday Night Magic on the 10th, I took this list in to give it a shot.  Truly, I was not as confident in this build as Tibbles and Bits, but I wanted to try it, nonetheless.

Here’s the list I played.

Creatures (8)

3 Vexing Devil
3 Chandra’s Phoenix
2 Falkenrath Aristocrat

Spells (30)

3 Bonfire of the Damned
3 Chandra, the Firebrand
2 Devil’s Play
3 Arc Trail
3 Brimstone Volley
4 Krenko’s Command
2 Bump in the Night
3 Incinerate
2 Tibalt, the Fiend Blooded
3 Tezzeret’s Gambit
2 Sphere of the Suns

Lands (22)

10 Mountain
4 Dragonskull Summit
4 Blackcleave Cliffs
2 Hellion Crucible
2 Swamp

Sideboard (15)

3 Combust
3 Nihil Spellbomb
3 Demolish
2 Runechanter’s Pike
2 Slagstorm
2 Sever the Bloodline

The goal of this deck was to capitalize on Chandra’s ability to copy powerful instants and sorceries as well as to compliment internal synergies.  A sacrificed Vexing Devil plus Brimstone Volley = nine damage, after all, fourteen if you doubled Brimstone Volley with Chandra.  Tibalt seemed fine here, providing some card selection while being on curve.  Hasty dudes could provide effective “burn” while the sideboard could help provide flexibility and reach, namely in the two Pikes, the Bloodlines and Demolish.  I liked Demolish here over Smelt because, although not as efficient, it was more flexible, helping me deal with problem lands like Cavern of Souls, Inkmoth Nexus or Kessig Wolf Run.  Also, a Turn 3 into a turn 4 minusing of Chandra killing TWO lands?  Seemed awesome, and it could win me the game on the spot. 

Let’s see how it did!

Round 1 – Patrick (Mono White Blinking Humans)

Patrick was a player I had never seen around the shop, and I’ve learned that new players often offer a tougher challenge than more familiar opponents.  He shuffled up a stack of worn-sleeved cards while I drew a fresh seven.  While staring at my loose keep, he created some small white creatures in the form of Cathedral Sanctifier and Grand Abolisher.  I made Tibalt, who ticked up and pitched well, staying just out of range of a lethal attack from Patrick’s squadron of dudes.  An Arc Trail helped me stabilize and I was able to get enough punch from Tibalt’s -4 that I cleaned him out while he was stuck on two lands.  In game 2, I kept a much better hand on 6, and I was able to maintain board advantage while he flooded out, never making much more than a pair of Attended Knights.

1-0

Round 2 – Korey (BUG Pod)

Korey, my opponent for the recorded Tibbles and Bits match, was playing a BUG Pod deck, a color combo of the archetype I hadn’t seen before. It sported Disciples of Bolas, Geralf’s Messengers, Phantasmal Images and Thragtusks.  In game one, he kept a strong hand, making roughly a billion Messengers while calmly swatting away my blockers, clearing a path for his Geralf-dozers.  I sided in my Zombie hate, which turned out to be essential in this match.  Severing his Messenger felt great, and Nihil Spellbombs kept his undying triggers honest.  As game 2 became a draw-go match, I ripped a Phoenix and suited it up with two lonely Pikes, giving him a formidable +2/+0.  Chipping away at him for four, he sat at 9 and passed the turn back.  I drew an Incinerate and thought for a moment.  I burned him first, making his life total 6, then I bashed with a now 6/2 Phoenix for exactly lethal.  Game three was also a close one.  I drew a lot and even paid blue to cast one of my Tezzeret’s Gambit; I drew all three that game.  For some reason, I cast one paying two life (when I didn’t have to), and, although I established a good position with Falkenrath and some Goblins, he found a Thragtusk with his Pod.  I killed his Thragtusk and hit him down to 4 with my team, thinking I surely had this one in the bag.  I, too, was at 4, but he didn’t have lethal on the board.  He cast two Blood Artists, sacked one (netting 0 life, but shrinking my total by 2), and found a Messenger, getting me to 0.

1-1

I wasn’t feeling very well, so I packed it up for the night.  The deck, with its attempted interactions with Chandra’s -2 ability, worked fine, but the original incarnation of Tibbles and Bits was much more consistent and higher on pressure.  The opponent was forced to stay on the backpedal with Diregraf Ghoul plugging away early and often, and the removal in Tibbles and Bits served a clearing purpose to help push my guys through, not just direct damage.  This deck was fun, though, and if you’re looking for a bit of a twist on mono-red burn with easy-to-get planeswalkers, you might want to give it a shot.

Reader Request

Finally, I was lucky enough to get a request for a unique deck for Standard revolving around a card that, as I see it, is most often relegated to the sideboard.  Thanks to Renwick Bromiley!

“Oooh…shiny…” – Ekrik, goblin scout, last words
Creatures entering the battlefield do not cause abilities to trigger.  That is a unique line of text from the entire library of Magic.  OK, so it shuts off “when this creature enters the battlefield” triggered abilities like Snapcaster Mage and “when another creature enters the battlefield” abilities, like Soul Warden’s trademark.  Interesting.

I love good deck challenges though, and Renwick already gave me a great start.  The first part of building the Torpor Orb deck is finding creatures that we don’t WANT their built-in triggers to occur.

As I pored over the menagerie of creatures we could use in Standard, I noticed a distinct shift from recent years to nearly all positive “ETB” abilities.  Magic’s history is full of creatures that give you power and efficiency in exchange for something negative when entering play.





In Standard, that list of creatures is pretty small.  Remwick gave me the idea for nearly all the creatures in this list, but the deck needed some fleshing out to conjure the other 45-odd cards we’d need.  He gave me…




Frankly, after doing some digging, I discovered this is about all of the creatures with negative ETB abilities in all of Standard.  They were in complementary colors, though, and, as an obvious favorite color combo for me, Rakdos it is!

Ok, so with Torpor Orb out, Treacherous Pit-Dweller and Vexing Devils are extremely efficient 4/3s that, when the Demon dies, just comes back as a 5/4 – the ETB trigger will never occur, but the undying trigger, which occurs as the creature dies, does occur, giving you the benefits of the good trigger without dissuading you with the bad trigger.  Demonlord of Ashmouth is even better, being a 5/4 flying trampler (that eats Restoration Angels and Delvers as a snack} that “undies” into a 6/5 flying trampler.  Big beats for sure!

As I assume this deck is on a bit of a budget, I’ll try to include cards that are fairly inexpensive to obtain (nothing over $5 a piece).  As we’ll be pulling from the whole canon of Standard, you might just have some of it already!

Creatures (17)

3 Hex Parasite
4 Vexing Devil
4 Treacherous Pit-Dweller
3 Demonlord of Ashmouth
3 Necrogen Scudder

Spells (20)

4 Torpor Orb
3 Pillar of Flame
3 Incinerate
3 Vile Rebirth
2 Trading Post
2 Sundial of the Infinite
3 Whipflare

Lands (23)

4 Blackcleave Cliffs
4 Dragonskull Summit
9 Swamp
4 Mountain
2 Buried Ruin

Sideboard (15)

2 Barter in Blood
3 Manic Vandal
3 Nihil Spellbomb
2 Sever the Bloodline
2 Killing Wave
2 Blood Artist
1 Falkenrath Aristocrat

In short, the goal of this deck is to stick a Torpor Orb on turn two and spend the rest of the game dropping ridiculously undercosted creatures while your opponent plays Snapcaster Mages as Ambush Vipers, their Acidic Slimes as five-mana Grizzly Bears, and their Geralf’s Messengers as a BBB Battered Golem (roughly).  There are tons of decks that obtain value mostly through powerful ETB abilities that create two-for-ones.  This one shuts done a ton of them. 

Deck Tech – Creatures

Hex Parasite

 
With eight copies of undying creatures in this deck, the Hex Parasite can keep each fresh and protected from removal while your Orb is out.  If it’s not, it can consume planeswalkers and +1/+1 counters of another creature.  Unmolested, it can eat a ‘walker and straight kill something in combat.  Also, and I think this one is funny, you can kill a Phantasmal Image for 2 life at instant speed. 

Vexing Devil, Treacherous Pit-Dweller, Demonlord of Ashmouth

These are the pilots of the deck, but they need the fuselage of Torpor Orb to fly.  Vexing Devil is fine without the Orb, dealing four for R, while the other two are slightly more reliant on it.  While the Pit-Dweller is a juicy target for removal while it’s out, the Orb destroys that incentive.  The Demonlord is a little sturdier, but not by a lot.  He is tough to burn out, but he still dies to Dismember on both sides.  Still, the prospect of Orbing with him in hand is pretty promising, and removal light decks will have a lot of trouble with a huge flyer on turn four. 

Necrogen Scudder

 
This Horror is probably the least dependent on the Orb, but as such, it has the lowest power level.  A 3/3 flyer for 2B that costs three life is a bit steep, but he’s fairly efficient and he becomes even more so with the Orb out.  Also, he’s pretty easy on the wallet as the only uncommon creature in this deck.  Turn three Scudder after turn two Orb is just fine.  He is more here to continue to be “on-theme” than an effective combatant; goodness knows you guys can probably think of something much better. 

Spells

Torpor Orb

The crown jewel of our strategy, it is an awkward, but necessary, playset in this deck.  They are dead if you draw more than one (assuming one is on the battlefield and safe.)  I still insist on four for two main reasons.  First, we have to draw it to win games in those tough, nail-biting matches.  At four copies in a deck of sixty, you have slightly less than 50% of a chance to draw one in your opener.  If your opener doesn’t have an Orb but is otherwise OK on curve, lands and spells, you should still consider throwing it back, as Orb is what makes this baby purr.  Secondly, especially post-board, Naturalizes, Ancient Grudges and Smelts will be floating around in your opponent’s hand.  You need to have a spare Orb in hand as often as possible when you perceive your opponent has artifact destruction available. 

Removal Suite (Pillar of Flame, Incinerate, Whipflare)

Red removal galore!  The first two are fairly cookie-cutter, and I play ‘em in just about every red deck I build for Standard.  Pillar is a great answer to a Bird, a Strangleroot Geist, a Geralf’s Messenger or any other “value creature” your opponent might play.  Incinerate is a great instant that is flexible enough to both thwart a Rancor placement and kill your opponent in a close, grindy match for just two mana.  Whipflare is an odd maindeck choice, but with the lack of artifact creatures that are frequently played in the format, you can consider this a Pyroclasm.  Also, if you’ll notice, it doesn’t kill any of our creatures!  The most vulnerable, Hex Parasite, is thankfully protected with its suddenly relevant supertype. 

Vile Rebirth


Still one of my favorite cards from M13, this was the last inclusion to the deck.  It was originally Altar’s Reap. Both serve a similar purpose, and I knew we’d needed a solution to a possible situation we could encounter. 

Here’s why we need either effect.  If something happens to our Treacherous Pit-Dweller, our most efficient beater, we need to have an answer to the Demon’s treacherous ETB trigger if there isn’t an Orb out.  While the undying trigger is on the stack, cast Vile Rebirth on your briefly binned Dweller, exile him, and end up with a 2/2, all for one B.  Alternatively, if you do have an Orb out, Rebirth can just function as a bit of graveyard control or as an instant speed combat trick.  I know, I still love this card way too much.  Altar’s Reap was cool, as it still let you salvage a botched Pit-Dweller situation, but for twice the mana and without much everyday use besides reacting to removal.  This didn’t sit well, so I threw it out in favor of this bargain.

Trading Post

This beauty, featured in the Tempered Steel deck today, also fits nicely here.  It gives your deck reach and strength in a variety of situations.  Perform the same sacrifice trick described above to keep a Pit-Dweller from changing sides, gain life lost by the Scudder’s trigger or by some scrapes and bruises from combat, recover a Smelted Orb from the graveyard or sacrifice/discard one of your extras.  Finally, and perhaps most flavorfully, you can create a Goat to sacrifice to the Demonlord.  How ‘bout THAT?

Still, this seems like a great choice; sideboard it out in a super-aggro match up if you just need more removal, but I don’t think you’ll be disappointed. 

Sundial of the Infinite

That's right, you MAIN PHASE that Think Twice!
This tricky little artifact will be a planning and skill tester.  I have included it to act like Torpor Orb’s #5 and #6, but it actually serves a broader purpose.  It can protect your creatures from removal (if it’s your turn), erase SNAFU-ed combat, or disrupt anything else your opponent wants to do on your turn.  Make sure you read this card carefully before using it, as it can end up hurting you as often as it helps.  Without a Stifle effect in Standard, this is where we have to go next.  Time Stop this is not, but it fits the bill and provides an interesting interaction with your opponent’s tricks. 

Lands

The mana base is pretty heavy black for the creatures and fairly heavy red for the removal, and the artifacts don’t care.  As such, most of the creatures need BB to cast, especially the Pit-Dweller (though don’t expect to want to cast him on turn 2 that often).  Buried Ruin, naturally, gets you back one of your precious combo pieces in case of fire. 

Sideboarding 

As with all my sideboarding, it’s usually specific to the metagame of the places I play.  Barter in Blood provides a lot of punch to kill powerful creatures and, if you get yours right back, no problem!  It’s good if you have an empty board too, say, if you’re fighting a high-density removal deck where you’re afraid to play your undying dudes without backup. 

Manic Vandal might be too cute, but he works nicely on an Orbed or a non-Orbed board (say that ten times fast.)  If there isn’t an Orb, he’s just a Scathe Zombies.  If there is no Orb, he can pick off a Birthing Pod, a Sword, an Elixir of Immortality, force an awkward Spellbomb sacrifice, or any other number of problem artifacts.  Smelt’s probably better, but the interactions!  THE INTERACTIONS, PEOPLE!

Nihil Spellbomb is fairly self-explanatory, though in a pinch, it can exile an awkward undying trigger on either side of the table.

Sever the Bloodline is a card that I liked when it first came out; after I stabled it for a while, I dug it back out and have been very pleased with it since.  It just kills a dude, and it does it well.  It kills tokens and it flashes back, giving this deck a little card advantage in the grindy matchups.  Also, specifically in this match, if Pit-Dwellers betray you in multiples, exile them both!  Bad Pit-Dwellers!  Go back to the basement!

As this is a fairly low creature count deck, Killing Wave will often put you on the winning end.  Huge threats on your side that you can just sack to the Wave and let them undie, if you want, put the pressure on them to keep their life total high.  If they pay, they die from a vicious Killing Wave life drain.  If they let their creatures die, you smash them with your efficient big guys!  It’s a great way to punish them for not blocking, too.  Blood Artist is also a nice sideboard inclusion to counter, well, another Blood Artist, as well as a high creature count deck.  Making them take 1 every time they Pod (3 if they pay for the Pod with life) is an efficient clock.  Your creatures undying or smashing their little chump blockers in attacks will also help the Blood Artist fit.  The Falkenrath Aristocrat is an efficient beater and a sac outlet on a stick, so you can use all of these guys in concert for a sacking machine!  I can’t tell you a matchup where these final five cards will be right, but you’ll know it when you see it. 

Let me know what you think of this attempt at a Torpor Orb deck!  Although I’d normally say, “there are a lot of ways you could do this deck,” I’m not sure there are a lot more ways to make an offensive, Torpor-Orb based deck in Standard.  In Modern, or even Legacy?  Well, the sky’s the limit, Johnnies!  Rest assured, Renwick, your deck’s future is assured with the myriad combos surrounding this artifact in Eternal formats.

Standard’s about to get a big shake up, and Return to Ravnica previews are on the horizon.  I hope you guys are excited to see what a return to the ecumenopolis of Ravnica will bring!

Until next time, don’t forget to untap!

- Matt H

Tuesday, August 7, 2012

Bump in the Night: Vampires in Post-M13 Standard


If you are looking for my Tibbles and Bits decklist and deck tech, click here! If you're interested in my most recent blog post, read on!



 
I’m just going to say it; I think the ancient Greeks had me in mind when they invented the Olympics.    A ton of sports, all at once, with contestants from all over the world.  It’s high action, there’s a lot of it, and it’s always on (well, for a couple weeks).  It’s like reality TV except it’s awesome.  It caters very well to my lack of durative attention, too.  “Aw, men’s rowing?  Pshaw, I’ll just wait five minutes and watch women’s synchronized table tennis!”  

W...what?

This is how I’ve felt lately about deckbuilding.  Don’t get me wrong, I love Tibalt and all of his awesome interactions and his sweet potential.  His deck is one of the most fun I’d made in a while.  It's synergetic, fun, interesting…I love it.  Still, though, I like to stretch my imagination, get my fingers dirty…

Last week I was out of town to visit my in-laws for a week.  It was awesome!  In my reprieve from work, I had a fair amount of downtime between tasty, home-cooked meals, outdoor excursions and air-conditioning to noodle on a deck I’d scribbled up before I left.  It revolves around a single card (as a lot of my decks do), and this one comes in the form of an unusual reprint from 2009.

Once you go black, you...well, you get +2/+1 and flying.
Not a ton of Vampire-matters cards right now.  Stromkirk Captain, sure…well, wait!  He’s red AND black!  He offers synergy in his abilities, his creature type AND his color…what if it ALL could be black?

Vampire Nocturnus has a specific problem in the current format.  He has a lot of vampire buddies, but some of them are red and therefore make his lord-like ability really awkward.  As it is, black/red vampire decks are pretty awkward and haven’t had any presence in the metagame.  I mean, it’s what I play on MTGO, but it’s because I’m cheap (or not antisocial, your choice), not because it’s good. 

So, everything needs to be black.  Yeah, it can be another color, but it’s got to be black too or it’s not in.  That way, Vampire Nocturnus will be online more often than he’s not.  Black is much deeper than it used to be back in Zendikar Vampire days, so there should be plenty we can do.  Black decks usually have to pick power over flexibility, but here, I think we can have our blood and drink it, too. 

After some tweaking, here’s an initial list.

Paint it Black

Creatures (20)

3 Vampire Nocturnus
3 Vampire Nighthawk
4 Stromkirk Captain   
3 Blood Artist
2 Dark Impostor
2 Falkenrath Aristocrat
3 Child of Night

Spells (17)

3 Sorin, Lord of Innistrad
3 Dead Weight
2 Sign in Blood
3 Dismember
3 Victim of Night
3 Cower in Fear

Lands (23)

9 Swamp
4 Dragonskull Summit
3 Isolated Chapel
3 Evolving Wilds
2 Mountain
1 Plains
1 Vault of the Archangel

Sideboard

3 Geth’s Verdict
3 Bump in the Night
2 Curse of Death’s Hold
3 Bonfire of the Damned
3 Appetite for Brains
1 Olivia Voldaren


Deck Tech – Creatures

Vampire Nocturnus

Right at the helm, Papa Midnight is the lord of choice.  It gives an immediate, almost Overrun-like effect (most of the time) making it a much sweeter topdeck than a lot of other four-drops.  With 37 cards that flip its switch, it’s a pretty sure bet that he’ll be online.  Compare it to Delver; most Delver decks I’ve seen only have about 16-30 cards that support it for the exact same effect (if you think about it, +2/+1 and flying,) except Papa pumps your whole squad.  The 1BBB cost is intimidating, but with 19 out of 23 lands providing black mana (either directly or indirectly via Evolving Wilds), this doesn’t seem to be much of a problem.  You won’t always want to play him turn 4 anyway.  He’s a great surprise.

Vampire Nighthawk

The awesomest of the awesome, Darkwing Duck is the bread and butter of a lot of black midrange decks, providing about as much versatility as you can hope for in mono-black.  He’s a vampire, he flies without help, he kills anything and he wins races!

Stromkirk Captain

An uncommon lord, for sure.
First strike is an immensely powerful combat ability, and the Captain helps everything else in this deck be awesome.  He’s the only non-land 4-of, and I think that’s because he’s just a solid man by himself.  He mucks up the ground, and a pair of them can safely block a Wurmcoil Engine, any Titan, a huge Champion of the Parish, or a Silverblade Paladin.  He’s pretty sweet.

Blood Artist

This painter has won me a lot of games.  It grinds out advantage, makes combat math very difficult, and he’s on-type.  With the Captain or the Nocturnus, he can even get in there!  I’ve learned that the Artist is not really a playset guy because of his uselessness in (most) combats, but I’m happy to include a trio.  He’s also an easy board-out if they’re playing anything besides uber-aggro.

Dark Impostor

You got a little...a little tissue, sir.
This one is a bit of a gamble.  On his own, he can take over any late game barring removal, and he can swell to overcome some stat-based removal (burn or Dismember-type effects).  Though, on his own…he’s just a Scathe Zombies.  Still, I’m OK with including him because of a growing trend I’ve observed in recent matches.  In an aggro-eat-aggro world like the one in which we currently live, we thrive on the topdeck (most of the time).  Even U/W Delver often devolves to that point in a lot of matches.  He’s premium removal on a stick and with him being on type, I can’t picture a better trickster in this slot.

Falkenrath Aristocrat

Ew, hellew!
A powerful and tough-to-kill finisher, this lass can close up tight races or provide an impregnable blocker.  A sacrifice outlet is also not bad on a mucked-up board where you control a Blood Artist.  Not much else to say about this bloody lady.

Child of Night

Just got his baby fangs in!
Let me state that I am not happy about playing French vanilla Baby Midnight here, but black vampires are in short supply right now.  Truthfully, though, on the play, he’s a fine attacker.  He also helps keep your opponent on the defensive, giving you that crucial turn to help you get there.  In concert with any other Vampire, he’s outstanding.  The Captain makes him a nigh-unblockable lifelinker or a superb wall.  Papa Midnight (the Nocturnus) makes him a 4/2 flying lifelinker.  That’s…that’s almost a Baneslayer!  Ok, maybe not…either way, I feel fine including him to give you a little more survivability on the back pedal while being an excellent rank-filler when you get in the red zone.

Spells

Sorin, Lord of Innistrad

Certified boss.
An exciting inclusion in this deck, he provides much needed card advantage, inevitability and versatility to an otherwise one-note machine.  He synergetically makes on-type minions, provides the extra +1/+0 to crack through the stalemate and his ultimate is terrifying and attainable, unmolested, by Turn 7.  He helps on the backpedal, and he should be a welcome draw on an empty board.  As basically the only reason I’m playing white, he’s gotta be good.

Dead Weight

I was trying to think about something better for this deck, but then...weight a minute...
This efficient enchantment is highly specialized to deal with a wide variety of early threats as well as some mid-game ones (Acidic Slime and Huntmaster come to mind.)  This deck has no one-drop creatures, and if they don’t play a creature, that’s probably better for this deck.  If they do, Dead Weight it!  It’s so easy!  But man, does it make me miss Disfigure…

Sign in Blood

Just sign on the clotted line.
This is not the first Vampire deck to play this on-flavor card.  I’m not sure this is right here, but this deck needs card advantage somehow.  It also can finish them off, and I have won my share of games that way.

Dismember, Victim of Night and Cower in Fear

My, what sharp...Voldo claws you have?
This is an unusual suite of removal, but I feel strongly about it.  Victims of Night are in here just because I don’t have Go for the Throats, and I’d rather play them as they’re easier to cast and they hit plum everything.  Dismember is easy on the mana and is darn convenient because of that.  I have enough lifelink that I’m not very concerned about paying life when I need to.  Cower in Fear is one of those underrated cards I mentioned, and so far, I’m pleased to play it.  It’s highly metagame specific; the places I play are swarming with mana dorks, tokens and Gavony Townships.  Killing your opponents’ Blade Splicer when they try to Restoration Angel it is a sweet feeling.  This is an easy board-out, but I’m fine with it in the maindeck.  That being said, it might not be right for you.  If your environment isn’t rife with white-knuckle aggro decks, it’s not even a sideboarder.

Lands

I’m really pleased with the land setup in this deck both in count, functionality and color weight.  In playtesting, I’ve always had the mana I need, though I ironically always seem to be short on black.  Three Evolving Wilds is pretty aggressive, but they serve an additional feature by thinning the deck, giving more possible online moments for Papa Midnight as well as stronger draws.  Normally two is sufficient in a multicolor deck, but without anything to do on Turn 1 on the play, evolving is a welcome play.

Sideboard

Admittedly, the sideboard is a circus of nonsense, but here’s some reasoning.

Bump in the Night and Bonfire of the Damned are probably the most unorthodox.  As opposed to a race, Bump in the Night gives me a non-combat way to close out games against a variety of decks.  It’s also a black Lava Spike that you can cast twice.  Six damage to a player for 5BR is not awesome, but it’s on the black-only theme while providing an alternative option to close out a game.  I’ve had a lot of games where the opponent stabilized at four or five and this just handles that situation.  Bonfire, although against theme, is just that good.  Also, if you so happen to have Nocturnus out with this face up on the top of your library, your opponent will play much differently, and so will you.

After some fiddling with this deck, I’m really pleased with the way it plays.  It’s weak to bounce, as most of my cards don’t have comes-into-play effects, but it’s a powerful creature deck that has flexibility and versatility unlike the vast majority of other aggro decks I’ve seen. 

I wanted to play this deck last night at Something2Do’s Tuesday tournament, but I was unable to get all the cards I was missing.  I hoped to get the last few rares I needed but I only got a four out of the seven.  I’ll need to postpone the play-by-play of that one for what I played instead; this is a fairly straightforward UR Delver, similar, though not as inventive, as my MiRUcle list.  Here’s what I hurriedly sleeved for the tournament yesterday.

DelvUR

Creatures (11)

4 Delver of Secrets
3 Augur of Bolas
4 Snapcaster Mage

Spells (27)

3 Krenko’s Command
4 Incinerate
3 Arc Trail
3 Bonfire of the Damned
4 Mana Leak
3 Dissipate
4 Vapor Snag
1 Brimstone Volley
2 Amass the Components

Lands (22)

4 Sulfur Falls
2 Evolving Wilds
1 Desolate Lighthouse
6 Mountain
9 Island

Sideboard

1 Talrand, the Sky Summoner
4 Pillar of Flame
2 Mental Misstep
2 Creeping Chill
3 Runecaster’s Pike
3 Flames of the Firebrand

Round 1 – Philip (G/W Aggro)

The round had already elapsed several minutes while I finished sleeving up the last of my cards, but Philip was very patient, content to shuffle for a while.  On the play in game one, he made an Avacyn’s Pilgrim.  I got a Delver down on my turn, but he didn’t flip for a while.  He made a Bird of Paradise and got stuck on two lands.  I started hitting him with a flipped Delver and Mana Leaked a Sublime Archangel from his side.  Another one appeared, but it was Incinerated, and Snapcaster to Mana Leak kept the third one from resolving.  I beat him down right after he drew his needed land.  In game two, he stalled on two land, cast a single creature, and I Bonfired him and smacked with Delver for exact.

1-0

This seemed like the perfect matchup for my deck made of Arc Trails, Krenko’s Command and Mana Leaks.  Maybe more uber-aggro decks like this would come…

Round 2 – Colin (Mono-Black Midrange)

I’ve played Colin many times before, and at least from my end, I always enjoy matches with him.  In Game 1, I countered and durdled for a while, getting him to about 10 life or so.  He resolved a Lashwrithe and, forgetting it had a Germ token attached, smashed me to pieces.  In game two, I got a slightly stronger draw and dodged his removal for a while.  I killed him definitively.  Game three was a bit more of a grind, with him casting Mutilates to kill single, unflipped Delvers.  I kept ripping Delver after Delver, though, and some unlucky choices from his Surgical Extractions and precariously low Sign in Bloods ticked up another win for me.

2-0

Round 3 – Tyler (U/W Delver)

Tyler, a very skilled player, shuffled up the heartbreaker and I recognized it right off the bat with his Seachrome Coast to Ponder.  His deck was air tight; suffice it to say, even after some awkward sideboarding on my part, I barely scratched him either game.

2-1

Round 4 – Ryan (RUG Humans)

Ryan, a kind and gracious player, was sitting behind a stack with a unique and intriguing mana base.  In Game One, I kept his Mayor of Avabrucks form sticking.  Bonfire did a ton of work too, sweeping his relatively small squad of Delvers and Mayors off the table.  I was able to crash in effectively with Snapcaster and Friends, decisively taking game 1.  In game 2, he flooded pretty hard while I beat him down with a single Krenko’s Command token (he Snagged the other one).  Intriguingly, he slow-rolled a Huntmaster of the Falls to turn 8, fearing a counterspell (all of which I had boarded out upon seeing Cavern of Souls.)  Amass the Components really shone in this game, always drawing me into the answer I needed.  A single Brimstone Volley was still enough, despite consistently anemic attacks from one and two-power boards.

3-1

Third place and three prize packs of M13 yielded little except my fourth Rancor and a couple Goat tokens, but as uninspired as this decklist was, it was pretty fun to play.  Krenko’s Command was arguably the most fun card to cast…I’m not sure why.  The sideboard also proved effective, and I did like having seven counterspells maindeck.  I might play a singleton Pike in the maindeck in the future, but overall, I was pleased with how it played.  Nothing stellar, but I’ll take it.

Pack to Power

Backing up before my vacation, I played a Friday Night Magic at my usual haunt with a slightly ill-fated revision of Tibbles and Bits, but I made good strides in my Pack to Power!  You win some, you lose some I guess.

The gentleman with whom both of these trades occurred is nameless to me; I’d recognize his name if I heard it, but he’s never directly introduced himself, so I’m left in that “hey…guy!” territory.  Either way, he was polishing off the final touches to his blue/black zombie deck before game time and, as he eyed my Phyrexian Crusader, he was happy to trade for my profit even after being clearly informed of the price difference.  What a trader!

Lost:
Phyexian Crusader - $1.49

Gained:
Think Twice (2) - $0.25 ($0.50)
Forbidden Alchemy - $0.25
Butcher Ghoul - $0.15
Goblin Arsonist (M12) (2) - $0.15 ($0.30)
Driver of the Dead (2) - $0.15 ($0.30)
[Elf Warrior Token] (4) - $0.49 ($1.96)
Grave Exchange - $0.15
Demonlord of Ashmouth - $0.75

Net Change - +$2.87

Well, the values on my gains are probably a bit exaggerated.  Regardless, I’ll take the acceptable amount of staple commons, some selection and some interesting trade bait in the tokens and the Demonlord.  Originally, I was fine with doing it just for the Demonlord and take a loss (as Phyrexian Crusader has, in my opinion, NO future in Modern), but he was willing to give me basically his whole stack of the only trade stuff he had on him.

Later in the evening, after the tournament, he told me he wanted the Drowned Catacomb I had.  He offered a stack to me, in which I found a Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker.  I was fine with trading up.

Lost:
Drowned Catacomb (M13) - $2.99

Gained:
Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker (M13) - $6.99

Net Change - +$4.00

Although the Catacomb is a lot more liquid, I was fine with making this trade.  Someone will want Nicol Bolas, and I think it will be fairly simple to trade him up for a better planeswalker; Garruk Relentless or Sorin, perhaps?  Even two Tibalts, though arguably at a loss, is in high demand and short supply despite his low price tag.  Brewers everywhere are getting Tibalt fever!

Total Net Change - +$6.87

Total Adjusted Pack Value as of August 1, 2012 –$28.66

I’m tossing around the idea of a couple other offbeat Standard decks that we’ll look at here in the next post or two.  I hope you want to paint it black, and let me know if you have any suggestions! 

Also, RTR is coming.



Thanks again for dropping by, and as always, don’t forget to untap!

- Matt H